The Ballad of Tom Dooley: A Novel by
Sharyn McCrumb
My rating:
4 of 5 stars
Sharyn McCrumb has written several novels exploring the facts behind traditional NC mountain ballads. In
The Ballad of Tom Dooley: A Novel, McCrumb re-interprets the true story of Tom Dula, hanged for the murder of Laura Foster, the kinswoman of his true love, Ann (Foster) Melton. In the novel, Pauline Foster, another kinswoman, travels down the mountain to Wilkes County to be treated for the pox - syphilis - by the local physician. Pauline decides to seek the hospitality of her cousin Ann & husband James Melton. Pauline is offended by her cousin's affair with Tom, her lack of interest in doing any work, or caring for her children. Ann carries on with Tom Dula (Dooley) in the house while her husband and Pauline sleep nearby. She leaves her two daughters in the care of her drunken mother. Pauline manipulates sundry and all to bring about the murder of young Laura, presumably by Ann. Zebulon Vance, senator and governor of North Carolina, narrates the legal side of the story. Tom is eventually hanged, and Ann goes free, due to her great beauty, according to Pauline.
McCrumb states that she has interviewed and researched to set her version as firmly in the facts of the case as possible. Pauline is certainly a character, interested only in herself, and taking revenge for slights against her.
If you have trouble accepting this version as a possible truth, I suggest you visit Wilkes county, NC and spend some time there.
View all my reviews